Davis DefenseCriminal Defense • Minnesota

Minnesota Implied Consent & Breath Test Refusal Defense

Refusing the test doesn’t end the case it often creates a new one. Get help before you make another move.

Attorney Andrew Davis

Can I Be Punished for Refusing the Breath Test?

In Minnesota, the answer is often yes. Under the implied consent law, if you are lawfully arrested on suspicion of DWI and refuse a requested breath test, you can be charged with a separate crime test refusal on top of any impaired driving charge. Many people believe that refusing to blow will protect them from a DWI conviction. In reality, refusal frequently leads to harsher penalties, both in criminal court and with the Department of Public Safety. Davis Defense helps you understand exactly what you are facing and how best to respond.

How Minnesota’s Implied Consent Law Works

Minnesota’s implied consent law says that anyone who drives on Minnesota roads is considered to have consented to chemical testing breath, blood, or urine to determine the presence of alcohol or drugs, if law enforcement has probable cause. The test is treated as a legal “search,” and refusing that search can itself be a crime. In many cases, the officer does not need a warrant for a breath test but may need one for blood or urine, depending on the situation and current law. The result is a complicated mix of criminal charges and civil license penalties that can be overwhelming without experienced legal help.

Consequences of a Breath Test Refusal

Refusing the test may feel like taking control, but the consequences are serious. A refusal can lead to:

  • A separate gross misdemeanor charge for test refusal, often punishable by up to 1 year in jail and a $3,000 fine.
  • Longer driver’s license revocation periods than a standard DWI in many situations.
  • Ignition interlock requirements or limited driving privileges, at your own expense.
  • Complicated court proceedings involving both the criminal case and the civil implied consent case.
  • Collateral consequences for employment, professional licenses, insurance, and more.

Breath, Blood, and Urine Tests After Legal Changes

Minnesota DWI law has changed significantly in recent years, especially regarding blood draws and warrants. Following decisions from the United States Supreme Court, it is unconstitutional in many situations to criminalize refusal of a warrantless blood test. As a result, for incidents after July 1, 2017, officers typically must choose: either offer a breath test and pursue refusal charges if you decline, or obtain a search warrant for a blood sample. These distinctions matter. Whether the officer read the correct advisory, obtained a valid warrant, and followed proper procedures can all affect the strength of the state’s case and the legality of any refusal charge.

Challenging Implied Consent and Test Refusal Cases

A refusal charge is not a foregone conclusion. Andrew looks closely at:

  • Whether the officer had a lawful basis to stop your vehicle
  • Whether there was probable cause for a DWI arrest
  • Whether the implied consent advisory was correctly read and explained
  • Whether you actually refused, or whether there were equipment or communication issues
  • Whether any blood or urine tests were properly requested, including warrants where required

What to Do After a Test Refusal in Minnesota

If you refused a test or are accused of refusing, your next steps are critical. Here’s how the process usually unfolds and how Davis Defense can help:

  1. Arrest and Advisory – You are arrested on suspicion of DWI and read the implied consent advisory explaining your testing options and potential consequences.
  2. Refusal or Test Result – You either refuse the test or provide a sample that may later be used against you in court.
  3. License Action – The state may move quickly to revoke your driver’s license based on the alleged refusal or test result, often with strict deadlines to challenge the revocation.
  4. Criminal Charges – You may be charged with DWI, test refusal, or both. Andrew reviews the reports, videos, and advisory to identify legal issues and defense strategies.
  5. Defense Strategy – We decide how to challenge the criminal case and the implied consent case, whether through motions, negotiations, or preparing for trial, with the goal of reducing or avoiding the long-term impact on your record and your ability to drive.

Minnesota Implied Consent & Test Refusal FAQ

What does “implied consent” mean in Minnesota?

Minnesota is an implied consent state. By driving on Minnesota roads, you are legally considered to have given your consent to a breath, blood, or urine test if law enforcement has probable cause to believe you are impaired. Refusing that test can itself be a separate crime and can trigger license consequences.

Can I be charged with both DWI and test refusal?

Yes. Test refusal is its own crime under Minnesota Statute § 169A.51. If you refuse the test and are also alleged to have driven while impaired, you can face two separate charges: one for the DWI and one for the refusal.

What are the penalties for refusing a breath test?

A criminal test refusal is a gross misdemeanor in many cases and can carry up to one year in jail, a fine of up to $3,000, and significant driver’s license consequences. The exact penalties depend on your prior record and other factors, which is why it is critical to speak with a lawyer as soon as possible.

Are blood and urine test refusals treated the same as breath test refusals?

Not exactly. Changes in the law, driven in part by decisions from the United States Supreme Court, limit when the state can criminalize refusal of a warrantless blood test. In many situations, officers must obtain a warrant before demanding a blood sample. The rules for breath tests and blood/urine tests are different and continue to evolve, which is why these cases require close legal analysis.

Does a test refusal automatically mean I lose my license?

A refusal almost always triggers separate driver’s license consequences under the civil implied consent process, which can include longer revocation periods than a simple DWI. However, you may have the right to challenge the revocation in court. Andrew can help you understand deadlines and options for fighting the license side of your case.

Locations Covered